The "John Doe is ?" game !

[RossRoy]

  Scarface ?

[Touti]

Scarface ?

Nope !

Edit:  , thinking.  The character's name in Scarface was "Tony Montana" but based on "Highlander" I have to give it to you but I was referring to Serpico.  You're Up !

[RossRoy]

Good thing! Because I have never seen Serpico 

Rowan Atkinson is J...

[Touti]

Good thing! Because I have never seen Serpico 

You've got to fix that...trust me.

[m.cellophane]

Good thing! Because I have never seen Serpico 

Rowan Atkinson is J...

Johnny English

Paul Newman is H...

[Touti]

Harry ?

[m.cellophane]

That wasn't the one I was thinking of, but it is a valid answer since he was in Harry & Son. 

[Touti]

Then it's not really a valid answer, remember, the name of the character is supposed to be the title of the movie.

As for the correct answer, I have no clue.

[m.cellophane]

OK then...we're still on Paul Newman is H... 

[Halo2]

Paul Newman is Hud?

[Touti]

Since M.Cellophane has not visited in a few days I checked on IMDB and it seems to be the correct answer.

Over to you Halo2

[Halo2]

Okay then, Tom Selick is Q

[lyonsden5]

Quigly

[Halo2]

Correct, the ball is in your court Rick.

[lyonsden5]

So far we have:

Kathy Bates is Dolores Clairborne
Alicia Morton is Annie
Dudley Moore is Arthur
Christopher Lambert is  Highlander
Robert Englund; Gerard Butler; Billy Zane; Lon Chaney (1883); is (are) Phantom of the Opera
Neil Patrick Harris is Doogie Howser MD
Al Pacino is Scarface and / or Serpico
Rowan Atkinson is Johnny English
Paul Newman is Hud
Tom Selick is Quigly



And now, the one that should stand out among all of these (especially if you've seen the movie)

Kirk Douglas is S...