• Welcome to DVD Collectors Online.
 

Blatantly false hype!

Started by RossRoy, March 10, 2008, 02:27:51 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

RossRoy

Ok, I have nothing against them* trying to push Blu-ray down my throat when I buy a DVD. But with blatantly false information?  :thumbdown:



And I'm not talking about the Blu image being sharper, but about the Blu image being wider than DVD!  :thumbdown:

Although I'm sure they were generous with the sharpening on the Blu and the blurring on the DVD.  :thumbdown:


* You probably already guessed, seeing the image, that I'm talking about Disney/BVHE

Touti

It's not impossible that they use a different aspect ratio.  Your image would tend to suggest that the DVD is 1:85 and Blu Ray is 2:35

RossRoy

Quote from: Touti on March 10, 2008, 02:38:55 AM
It's not impossible that they use a different aspect ratio.  Your image would tend to suggest that the DVD is 1:85 and Blu Ray is 2:35

Still, it's not an "advantage" of Blu-ray over DVD.. It's a conscious decision to make Blu-ray look better than DVD in an area where DVD can equal Blu-ray (AR).

Tom

Quote from: Touti on March 10, 2008, 02:38:55 AM
It's not impossible that they use a different aspect ratio.  Your image would tend to suggest that the DVD is 1:85 and Blu Ray is 2:35

For me it looks like they used a 4:3 DVD image. My DVD release of cars is 2.40. It is also available in the US as FF 1.33, I believe. And this is what they used for comparison IMO.



Touti

I think you're right about 4:3 Tom.  I was looking at it on my widescreen TV set to 800x600 resolution so everything is stretched a bit.