Topic: Directors Best Poll #7 - Kevin Smith

[Antares]

Chasing Amy
Clerks   
Dogma
   
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back    
Zack and Miri Make a Porno

Mallrats

I really thought he was going to be the best of his generation, but he has really shit the bed since Dogma.

[snowcat]

Clerks
Chasing Amy
Jersey Girl

Mallrats
Zack and Miri Make a Porno

Dogma

Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back
Clerks 2

Im a big fan of Kevin Smith, and I guess I just don't get what people see in Dogma.

I bought Cop Out recently, I really need to watch that.

I felt Zack and Miri was his best film for a long time.

and yep, I highly rate Jersey Girl 

[Najemikon]

I'd go the same as Antares, except switch Clerks and Amy. Dogma is probably his career high and I bet he'd love to get some of that controversy now. I saw Cop Out the other week. Really wasn't actually terrible, but wasn't great. Seann William Scott absolutely steals it! I think Red State and his hockey film he almost has in production will be make or break. I still think he has far more potential than the Apatow stable, but he has to start delivering.

Still, his Evening With DVDs are good. I still love his Superman anecdote...  

[snowcat]

I think Kev definitely has more potential then the Apatow films, however he once said on smodcast (along the lines of) "Judd Apatow makes better Kevin Smith movies then I do" I see where he was going with that, but I think hes grown up past the View Askewniverse days and can only go on to better things.

[KinkyCyborg]

Jersey Girl

Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back

I own all of Kevin Smith's movies save for Red State and have only watched the two above. I watched the trailer for Red State a month or so ago and would have never have guessed that it is a Kevin Smith movie! Very intrigued to see it now as unless the trailer is meant to completely fool you, he's now going in a completely different direction with this one.

[m.cellophane]

Jersey Girl

Clerks
Chasing Amy

Mallrats

Haven't Seen:
Dogma
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back
Clerks II
Zack and Miri Make a Porno
Cop Out
Red State

[Mustrum_Ridcully]

Chasing Amy
Dogma
   
Jersey Girl   
Zack and Miri Make a Porno (if anyone is interested in the original idea try: Pornorama)

[Achim]

Clerks
Dogma

Chasing Amy
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back
Clerks II
Zack and Miri Make a Porno


MallratsJersey Girl

Not seen:
Cop Out (don't care)
Red State (want)