DVD Collectors Online

DVD Reviews => The "Marathon" reviews => Topic started by: Touti on October 02, 2009, 01:54:24 AM

Title: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 02, 2009, 01:54:24 AM
As stated in a previous post I've decided to join in this year and participate in this marathon although I'm not a huge fan of the genre and I don't own many horror movies.

I previously said I only own 6 and would watch them all this month but I've decided to push a little and either acquire new horror movies or rent some to increase my watching.  Time is not really an issue but budget is so I don't know how many I will watch.

I will do my best to post reviews although I don't feel very good at it but in the event that I don't know what to say I will at least give each movie a score on a scale from 1 to 5 with half values using the following icons.

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror1.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror1.5.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror2.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror2.5.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror3.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror3.5.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror4.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror4.5.jpg)

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror5.jpg)



Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: addicted2dvd on October 02, 2009, 02:07:16 AM
very cool Eric! Great Icons!  :thumbup:
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 02, 2009, 02:24:16 AM
Where do you guys/girls draw the line between horror and suspense/thriller.  I'm going through my collection to see if I can stretch things a little and include more stuff.  Would you consider these as horror ?

Frankenstein
Silence of the Lambs
Misery

I think I remember reading about the first 2 in the forum earlier this week and that they could count. 

If TV Series are allowed then I also have "Grande Ourse" and "L'héritière de Grande Ourse" which I think could be considered as horror, I'm sure Jimmy and Seb have seen them so they can probably give an opinion on that.

Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: RossRoy on October 02, 2009, 02:37:18 AM
If TV Series are allowed then I also have "Grande Ourse" and "L'héritière de Grande Ourse" which I think could be considered as horror, I'm sure Jimmy and Seb have seen them so they can probably give an opinion on that.

Grande Ourse can go either way. It deals with spirits and the occult, so it fits horror, but I do feel it is more a suspense/thriller than horror. But like I said, either way goes.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 02, 2009, 03:03:05 AM
Columbia House has a special going on for members.  You buy 1 movie at regular price and you can get as many as you want of same or lower value at 50% off.

I ordered

Pan's Labyrinth
Otis: Uncut
Land of the Dead: Unrated Director's cut

With my 4 Japanese movies and maybe a few rentals I should be good for a month.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Dragonfire on October 02, 2009, 03:24:47 AM
I definitely consider Frankenstein horror.  Misery and Silence of the Lambs fit as horror for me too..though it is a different type.  The first time I saw Silence of the Lambs, it really freaked me out..and I was periodically hiding behind a pillow.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Jimmy on October 02, 2009, 03:58:36 AM
Sorry Eric, I've never watch "Grande ourse" since I don't really watch a lot of our tv (it's always the same people). In fact one of the only TV show that I watch on our tv is "Une grenade avec ça" (I know I'm not really the age target for this show :-[, but Catherine Proulx-Lemay and Rose-Maïté Erkoreka are in this :whistle:)

I've check your collection and I think that you could count those as horror :

I Am Legend, Misery, Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, Hide and Seek and,of course, the Japanese movies.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: addicted2dvd on October 02, 2009, 12:46:50 PM
That is why I make mine a Horror/Halloween marathon... that way if it is anything I like to watch this time of the year... it counts!  :thumbup:

Personally I say if you want it to count... then it counts. I am definitely not strict about such things!  :)
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 03, 2009, 12:31:04 AM
Marathon starts now.

Isola


Overview: The second film based on the works of award-winning novelist, Yasuke Kishi. When Yukari, a psychic able to read the thoughts of other, comes to help suvivors of the 1995 Kobe earthquake, she encounters a trouble girl named Chichiro who is suffering from Multiple Personality Disorder. Chichiro has 13th different personalities and her 13th personality is a revengeful ghost named Isola. Can the psychic find a way to stop Isola without harming Chichiro ?

My Thoughts: I'm a bit puzzled by this movie.  Not that it isn't good but not what I would expect from a horror movie.  It's difficult to judge this one because it's made by and with people from a culture I know very little about.  I think what leaves me puzzled is that the chararacters don't show much emotion, even when they're scared or hurt, they're all a bit cold all the time.  On the other hand it's not necessarily a bad thing as it adds to the strangeness (is this a word ?) to the movie which it can use as it needs something to compensate for a little lack of action you would normally find in horror movies.  Watching a Japanese horror movie with English subtitles was an interesting experience nonetheless.

My Score:

(http://www.touti.net/images/Horror3.jpg)
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 03, 2009, 06:10:04 PM
I know I only signed up for a "Best effort" marathon but I only watched one movie so far so I think it's time for me to do a few more.  After lunch I'm gonna watch "Misery" which I haven't seen in a few years.  After that I'll probably read a little and hopefully fall asleep for a few hours.

Tonight I'm gonna watch "The silence fo the lambs" starting at 10:00 which should put me right on time for the Japanese F1 race.


Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: richierich on October 03, 2009, 06:13:57 PM
I know I only signed up for a "Best effort" marathon but I only watched one movie so far so I think it's time for me to do a few more.  After lunch I'm gonna watch "Misery" which I haven't seen in a few years.  After that I'll probably read a little and hopefully fall asleep for a few hours.

Tonight I'm gonna watch "The silence fo the lambs" starting at 10:00 which should put me right on time for the Japanese F1 race.




Interested to see your review of Misery, it's one of those films I didn't originally warm to as I kept comparing it to the book. Might give it another go this month.
Should be a good F1 race, given all the penalties imposed which has mixed up the starting grid nicely.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 03, 2009, 06:42:59 PM
Should be a good F1 race, given all the penalties imposed which has mixed up the starting grid nicely.

Yeah definitely, especially on a fast track like Suzuka.  I think Kimi is in a pretty good position to claim the win, most fast cars will be behind and he's got Kers................while others seems to only have curse ;)
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 03, 2009, 09:22:13 PM
Misery




Overview:Paul Sheldon (James Caan) barely remembers the blinding blizzard that sent his car spinning off the road into a near fatal accident. Nor does he remember being nursed back from unconsciousness. All he does remember is waking up to the worst nightmare of his life.

Rescued from the accident by his self-confessed number one fan, Paul Sheldon learns that Annie lives vicariously through his novels based on the character Misery Chastain. Grateful to Annie for saving his life, Paul allows her to be the first to read his new manuscript.

From that point on it becomes increasingly clear that Annie has trouble distinguishing fact from fiction and Paul comes to the harrowing realization that he might never leave the home of Annie Wilkes alive.

My Thoughts:  Misery has always been and still is one my favorite movies for a few reasons.  First, it's in this movie that I saw Kathy Bates for the first time.  She always gives wonderful performances but in Misery she's just brilliant.  The way she plays the different faces of her character is so credible it makes the viewer feel like he's watching a reality show.  Annie (Bates' character) is a not too bright girl, a bit naive in her views of the world but within a snap she can turn into this monster who takes pleasure in hurting this man she's sequestering while claiming she loves him while what she actually loves is the control she (finally ?) has over something.

This is one of a very movies that I find hard to watch because of the way the violence is showed......or not.  The director took a very interesting approach in getting to us not by showing violence but by showing, and making us feel, the pain associated with it.  Misery has got this very nasty way of showing you how and how much pain Paul Sheldon is about to endure and as if this wasn't enough, the director always gives you a few seconds or minute to realize how bad it's gonna hurt..................almost making you hurt as well.

(click to show/hide)

After having seem that movie so many times I can still almost feel that pain myself and this will always remain one of my favorite suspense movie.

I give it a perfect score.

(http://touti.net/images/Horror5.jpg)

Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: addicted2dvd on October 03, 2009, 09:24:37 PM
I haven't watched Misery in a while! It is definitely a great movie.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Achim on October 04, 2009, 10:20:56 PM
I also think that Misery is an awesome movie and will probably upgrade my non-anamorphic DVD to Blu-ray soon. Performances are great throughout Kathy Bates leads, but also James Caan and the guy who plays the sheriff are great to watch.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: snowcat on October 04, 2009, 10:47:22 PM
I love Misery, I read the book first and loved it, although there are some slight changes between the two, I think they are both great. I will have to get the film on DVD I have the VHS.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Kathy on October 04, 2009, 10:51:25 PM
I love Misery, I read the book first and loved it, although there are some slight changes between the two, I think they are both great. I will have to get the film on DVD I have the VHS.

The Shining is another terrific King book - I liked it as much as the movie.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 04, 2009, 11:04:06 PM
The Silence of the Lambs




Overview: One of the most shocking, compelling and diabolical crime thrillers ever made is even more delectable on Blu-ray! Including in-depth documentaries about the film's journey from page to screen, exclusive new interviews with Jodie Foster, Sir Anthony Hopkins and Scott Glenn in the feature-length Breaking the Silence, generous servings of deleted scenes, still photos and outtakes – and much more, this powerful, five-time Academy Award® Winner* will chill you to the bone. When FBI Agent Clarice Starling (Jodie Foster) is assigned a case involving a monstrous serial killer, she seeks counsel from an imprisoned cannibalistic psychiatrist – Dr. Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins), whose fascination with the young woman is as great as his hunger for murder. As their relationship develops, Starling must confront her own demons – and an evil so powerful that she may not have the courage or strength to stop it!

*1991: Best Picture, Directing, Actor (Anthony Hopkins), Actress (Jodie Foster), Adapted Screenplay

My Thoughts:  What could I possibly write about this movie that hasn't already been said many times and in a much better way.  Although I've seen it many times and know what's gonna happen I can still feel the tension when I watch it. 

The Blu-Ray version is definitely worth buying.

A perfect score

(http://touti.net/images/Horror5.jpg)
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 04, 2009, 11:42:43 PM
I'm checking the bonus materials on this DVD, there's some nice stuff.  In the "Documentaries" section there's one called "Breaking the silence".  I thought it was gonna be a featurette or something like that but it's actually a full replay of the movie with comments from the actors as it plays.  The nice thing is that instead of being audio only it uses picture in picture and you can see the person while he/she comments the scene.

Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 12, 2009, 11:14:40 PM
Shadow of the Wraith


Overview:Two brothers are plunged into the realm of psychic horror, one tormented by a stalker, and the other involved with a girl whose home is the site of eerie occurances.

Asaji is in love with Ryoji. Ryoji senses his presence wherever he goes, but he figures it's just a crush and that it won't go much further, but he couldn't be more wrong as Asaji begins stalking Mariko, Ryoji's girlfriend. When a female friend of Ryoji is killed in an accident while talking with him on phone, her last word is, "Asaji ...". But, she couldn't be involved, she was with Ryoji at the moment of her death ...

As soon as Naoko moves into room 505 of her new appartement, she hears sories about strange accidents and eerie phenomena surrounding appartements with the number "5". She runs into Kazuhiko, Ryoji's brother, whom she saw taking photos of her condo. He won't say what he was doing, but he warns her to be careful.Accidents continue to happen in condos with the number "5" and something in Naoko's closet is taking a gruesome form.

My Thoughts: I guess Horror really isn't my cup of tea.  I actually dozed off a few times during that movie.  Actually it's not 1 movie.  It's split in two parts but except for a few characters that appear in both they not related whatsoever.

My Score: (http://touti.net/images/Horror2.5.jpg)


Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Najemikon on October 12, 2009, 11:57:09 PM
I do think the best new examples of proper scary horrors are coming from the East, however, they copy each other. A lot. Ringu was a massive success, so they all started making their demons scary girls with long dark hair. Heck, even the game F.E.A.R. nick is wholesale! It may be you're mining a vein of copycats with that set.

The trick to the successful ones is that they are solid dramas, without any need for theatrics. Problem is though that the copycats can't pull it off, so they end up... boring. Or so enigmatic they're impenetrable.

Try Ringu, Dark Water and A Tale of Two Sisters. Throw in Battle Royale and you've had a taste of the key styles and if you don't like them, then they are definitely not your thing. If you do, there's The Eye, The Grudge and Shutter to look forward to...  ;)
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Jimmy on October 13, 2009, 12:15:32 AM
Battle Royale
Even if this is an excellent Japanese movie this isn't an horror movie. Action, Drama and science Fiction (maybe), but no horror here...
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 13, 2009, 12:22:53 AM
I use to enjoy horror movie.  I had quite some fun with the early "Friday the 13th" series, I loved (and still enjoy) "Carrie" or the "Exorcists" movies.  Then at some point I lost interest in it because everything that came out seemed utterly stupid.  In movies like Carrie, The Exorcist, Poltergeist and the likes there is a story to support the movie but there seems to have come a point where everything was about blood and special effects and a bunch of movies came out with no story at all.

I hope this won't insult those who enjoy them but I find movies like "Texas Chainsaw Massacre" or the "Saw" series so ridiculous they don't even amuse me.  Maybe there's sub-genres in horror movies and some are just not my type ?

Movies I consider Horror and would gladly watch again.

Carrie
The Exorcist (All of them)
Stigmata
Constantine

I've taken a big risk in ordering BR versions of "Land of the Dead", "Otis" and "Pan's Labyrinth" but they all had some reasonably high scores on Rotten Tomatoes so I took the chance.  I'll see after I get them............maybe one of you will have a chance to buy 3 horror blu-rays at half price ;)
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Najemikon on October 13, 2009, 08:05:46 AM
Battle Royale
Even if this is an excellent Japanese movie this isn't an horror movie. Action, Drama and science Fiction (maybe), but no horror here...

No, it is fundamentally fantasy, leaning strongly to horror, not drama. It doesn't exist and is a high-concept idea, so it can't be merely drama. Not science-fiction really and you don't watch it just for action sequences. It's definitely fantasy, and so is horror.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Najemikon on October 13, 2009, 08:08:27 AM
I hope this won't insult those who enjoy them but I find movies like "Texas Chainsaw Massacre" or the "Saw" series so ridiculous they don't even amuse me.  Maybe there's sub-genres in horror movies and some are just not my type ?

Only if you mean the original TCM! If you're mentioning it in the same breath as Saw, you should be punished! Otherwise, I agree... ;)



Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Achim on October 13, 2009, 01:13:03 PM
The Exorcist (All of them)
:redcard:

Never seen it myself, but I trust the legions of people who say that The Exorcist II: The Heretic is among the most terrible movies ever made.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Touti on October 13, 2009, 02:41:01 PM
I'll have to trust you on that Achim, it's been so long since I've seen any of them that I don't really remember what's in each one.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: addicted2dvd on October 13, 2009, 06:20:08 PM
The Exorcist (All of them)
:redcard:

Never seen it myself, but I trust the legions of people who say that The Exorcist II: The Heretic is among the most terrible movies ever made.

The Exorcist II is so bad... I don't even acknowledge it's existence. And this is coming from someone that enjoyed The Omen 4!  :tease:
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Jimmy on October 13, 2009, 06:51:57 PM
The Exorcist II is so bad... I don't even acknowledge it's existence.
It isn't that bad. Linda Blair look good in it and  :hmmmm:

Nothing else, this is the only positive thing I can say about this movie.
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Najemikon on October 13, 2009, 06:52:35 PM
The Exorcist (All of them)
:redcard:

Never seen it myself, but I trust the legions of people who say that The Exorcist II: The Heretic is among the most terrible movies ever made.

The Exorcist II is so bad... I don't even acknowledge it's existence. And this is coming from someone that enjoyed The Omen 4!  :tease:

There's an Omen 4? ???


Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: addicted2dvd on October 13, 2009, 07:03:01 PM
 :laugh:
Title: Re: Eric's 2009 "Best Effort" October Horror Marathon.
Post by: Dragonfire on October 13, 2009, 09:55:11 PM
The Exorcist (All of them)
:redcard:

Never seen it myself, but I trust the legions of people who say that The Exorcist II: The Heretic is among the most terrible movies ever made.

The Exorcist II is so bad... I don't even acknowledge it's existence. And this is coming from someone that enjoyed The Omen 4!  :tease:

The Exorcist II sucks.  And this is from someone who enjoys Howard the Duck.   :laugh:  Yes I know that one isn't that great either, but it is better than The Exorcist II.  I haven't seen The Omen 4...at least I don't think I have.  I saw part of one of the sequels once that I didn't like much..though I thought it was the third one.  Either way, Exorcist II sucks.